Crispy, warm, and ready in 10-minutes! This Peanut Butter Banana Sandwich turns a classic snack into a golden, melty treat. Perfect for quick breakfast, kid-friendly snacks, or healthy dessert ideas. Includes tips, variations, and flavor enhancers. Make this easy 5-ingredient Banana PB&J sandwich in air fryer as well as on the stove grill.
Banana is my favorite fruit when it comes to baking delicious desserts and sweets. Vegan Banana Bread, Banana Walnut Muffins, Chocolate Banana Bread and Banana Oatmeal Raisin Cookies all amazing recipes to use all the leftover browned bananas.
Jump to:
This protein rich vegetarian sandwich is perfect for on-the-go breakfast, casual brunch or lunch or after school snack. It is portable so you can also use it for picnic or travel meals as well.
Peanut butter and jelly were my favorite pairings since childhood. There are multiple ways to eat it. I like it on toast. For kids, I often make banana sushi with sliced bananas drizzled with peanut butter, jelly and some cinnamon powder drizzled on top.
This easy grilled peanut butter banana sandwich recipe only requires 5 ingredients. Plus it is low cost meal since all the ingredients are inexpensive and easy to find in regular grocery store.
Why This Recipe Works
- It is quick and easy
- Well liked with classic traditional flavors
- Needs just 5 simple ingredients and 10 minutes
- Inexpensive and low cost to make
- Healthy, wholesome and satisfying
- Kid-friendly
- Gluten free and vegan option
Ingredients
- Bread: I prefer to use whole grain slice of bread to amp up the wholesomeness. You can use whichever bread you have easily available. whole wheat, sourdough, brioche, or white bread works too.
- Peanut Butter - creamy melts best, crunchy adds texture.
- Banana - Ripe but firm banana is the best option. Cut thin slices.
- Fruit Jam or Jelly : Your favorite fruit preserve like strawberry jam, raspberry or blueberry jelly
- Butter - Use plant based for vegan option.
Optional Enhancers : - Honey or maple syrup
- Cinnamon or cinnamon sugar
- Chocolate chips or chopped nuts
✨Thicker bread (like sourdough or brioche) holds fillings better and crisps more evenly.
Variations
- Switch it up by using different fresh fruits instead of banana. Diced strawberries, blueberries or raspberries, sliced apples, pears, grapes, mangoes or peaches are all good options. This is a good list for that.
- Make it interesting for kids : my kids love different shapes of sandwich in their lunch box. So use cookie cutters and make variety of different shapes instead of just triangular or rectangular sandwich. How about heart shaped sandwich for Valentines Day, pumpkin shapes for Halloween, gingerbread man sandwich for Christmas?
- Different Nut Butters : Seed butter, sun-butter which is sunflower seed butter, cashew butter, Almond butter or Nutella can be used instead of classic peanut butter.
- Add Flavors : You can sprinkle ground cinnamon, nutmeg, allspice, apple pie spice, pumpkin pie spice for added flavors.
- Instead of fruit jam or jelly, use honey, maple syrup or orange marmalade. You can also choose sugar free option if needed.
- Make it gluten free peanut butter sandwich: Use certified gluten free bread instead of the whole grain wheat bread to make this sandwich gluten free.
- Indulgent options : Adding a layer of marshmallow fluff, chocolate chips, cookie butter, chocolate syrup or caramel sauce to make it a melty dessert sandwich.
- Sprinkle chia or flax seeds for added protein and fiber.
How To Make Banana PB&J
Prepare and Layer The Sandwich: Spread the peanut butter onto the slice of bread. Spread the fruit jelly onto the remaining slice of bread. Place banana slices on top of the bread with peanut butter. Put the bread with jelly spread on the top and press down so it sticks to the bottom bread. Spread some butter on the outer sides of the sandwich.
Air Fryer Option : Air fry at 350 °Fahrenheit for 5 minutes. Check for doneness. Add extra 2 minutes if needed. Outer sides of the bread should be golden brown toast.
Stove Top Grill Sandwiches : Warm up the griddle, grill pan or normal pan on medium high heat. Place the sandwich on the griddle. Toast on both sides until golden brown.
Serve : Remove promptly. Cut diagonally to make triangular sandwiches. Serve immediately and enjoy !
✨You can also use panini press or sandwich press to make these grilled sandwiches.
Does Banana Peanut Butter Sandwich Cause Weight Gain?
This peanut butter banana sandwich is complete wholesome meal full of heart healthy fats, potassium, and carbohydrates and fiber from whole grain bread. One peanut butter sandwich has .. calories,
Moderation and variety are two important components of healthy weight management. So balanced diet like this peanut butter sandwich paired with fresh vegetables should be good addition in healthy eating.
This sandwich can also keep you full and satisfied for few hours. This will help cut down on eating or snacking between meals.
Is this Recipe Vegan?
If you use use plant based butter or vegetable spread , this sandwich is vegan.
How to make this sandwich Gluten Free?
Use certified gluten free products including gluten free bread to make this sandwich.
What banana ripeness works best in the air fryer?
Use yellow bananas with slight brown spots. Overripe bananas release too much moisture and make the sandwich soggy.
How do I keep the filling from leaking out?
Don’t overfill, keep banana slices flat, and lightly press the sandwich before air frying. Thicker bread helps contain soft fillings.
More Brunch Recipes
- Multigrain Savory Waffles
- Tofu Scramble
- Sweet Potato Stir Fry
- Pumpkin Spice Muffins
- Kale Apple Superfood Smoothie
Chocolate Chia Pudding, Avocado Toast, Almond Flour Mug Cake and Homemade Granola are few other recipe ideas for quick and satisfying start of the day besides this recipe.
★ If you make this Banana Peanut Butter Sandwich Recipe, do let us know how you like it by ★ star rating it and leaving a comment below.
📖 Recipe
Peanut Butter Banana Sandwich (Air Fryer Option)
Ingredients
- 4 Pieces of bread I used whole grain white
- 1 medium firm ripe Banana cut into round slices
- 2 Tablespoon Peanut Butter creamy
- 2 Tablespoon Fruit jam/ jelly or preserve
- 1 teaspoon butter melted use plant based for vegan option
Instructions
Prepare the Sandwich
- Spread the peanut butter onto two bread slices. Spread the fruit jelly onto the rest of the two bread slices. Spread the cut up banana slices on top of the bread with peanut butter. Put the bread with jelly spread on the top and press down so it sticks to the bottom bread. Spread some butter on the outer sides of the sandwich.
How to make Grilled Peanut butter banana sandwich in Air Fryer
- Air fry at 350 °Fahrenheit for 5 minutes. Check for doneness. Add extra 2 minutes if needed. Outer sides of the bread should be golden brown toast.
How to make Grilled Peanut butter banana sandwich on Stove Top Grill
- Warm up the griddle on medium high heat. Place the sandwich on the griddle. Toast on both sides until golden brown.
Serve
- Remove promptly. Cut diagonally to make triangular sandwiches. Serve immediately and enjoy !
Notes
Storage
- Best eaten fresh
- Can refrigerate wrapped tightly for up to 24–48 hours
How to Serve and Pair Your Sandwich
This sandwich works well as:- Breakfast with coffee or smoothies
- After-school snack
- Light dessert
- Greek yogurt and berries
- Apple slices with cinnamon
- A protein shake
Nutrition
❤️❤️ Follow us on Pinterest , Instagram and Facebook ! We love creating delicious family favorite recipes from around the world. Come Join Us ! ❤️❤️
This recipe was first published on ProfusionCurry Website on January 2022.
Why Use an Air Fryer for This Sandwich?
Air frying works especially well for soft-filled sandwiches like peanut butter and banana because it:
- Creates a crispy exterior without deep frying
- Heats the filling evenly
- Prevents soggy bread (common in microwaves)
- Cooks faster than an oven or toaster
air fryer banana peanut butter, pb and banana sandwich, banana peanut butter air fryer snack, peanut butter banana sandwich, banana in air fryer with peanut butter,
Leave a Reply